Compare equivalent finished performance
A lower pigment price does not by itself establish a lower formulation cost. Compare coating coverage, film thickness and the loading required to meet the same target. Include dispersion time and other process effects where they affect production.
Measure more than initial whiteness
Evaluate hiding power, undertone, gloss, viscosity and storage stability using consistent methods. A small colour difference can matter in a tinted coating. Review the results at the film thickness and drying conditions relevant to the finished product.
Consider the exposure conditions
Interior and exterior coatings face different demands. A pigment package that works in an indoor primer may not meet the needs of an outdoor topcoat. Assess weathering, water resistance and other required properties at the formulation level.
Confirm changes through trials
When considering lithopone or another change to a titanium dioxide pigment package, test multiple formulations against an approved control. Replacement ratios and cost savings must be demonstrated in your system. Request grade information and samples before making a commercial change.
For the identity of the rutile pigment family, see NIST Chemistry WebBook: rutile (TiO2). Compare commercial grades using current technical data and equivalent finished-coating tests.

Compare the cost of the accepted coating
| Measure | Why it changes the comparison |
|---|---|
| Contrast ratio at fixed film thickness | Shows whether the pigment package meets the same hiding requirement. |
| Application viscosity and binder demand | Changes application behaviour and sometimes the formulation cost. |
| Coverage and dry-film thickness | Relates the formulation to the area coated at the specified performance. |
| Storage and service performance | Reveals settling, colour drift or durability failures missed by an initial drawdown. |
First establish the minimum acceptable opacity, gloss, colour and durability. Then compare formulas that meet those limits. Dividing one pigment’s price by another’s price ignores loading, binder consumption, processing effort and rejected material. An apparent saving in pigment cost can disappear if the paint requires more coats.
A controlled substitution sequence
Keep a retained control and create a documented series of small formulation changes. For a partial lithopone substitution, compare B-301 or B-311 in the intended interior formulation. Review the TiO2 grade and the pigment volume concentration before interpreting the results.
For exterior systems, include the exposure and durability requirements in the test plan. Confirm accepted performance before calculating cost per unit of finished paint or per coated area. The Longtai catalog provides a product shortlist; it does not replace testing in the customer’s binder.
